Dating the crucifixion.

Every clue used to date Jesus' death, from the terms of Pilate and Caiaphas to the phases of the moon, each graded for how firm it is. The Passover dates for 26-36 CE are worked out from astronomy, with the method explained.

Firm 3Computed 1Probable 3Disputed 2Weak 3
Josephus, Ant. 18.89; Tacitus, Annals 15.44; the Pilate stone

Pilate was prefect of Judaea

Pilate governed Judaea for about ten years, from 26 to late 36 or early 37.

Firm
Josephus, Ant. 18.35, 18.95

Caiaphas was high priest

Joseph Caiaphas held the high priesthood through the whole of Pilate's term.

Firm
Mark 15:42; Matt 27:62; Luke 23:54; John 19:31, 42

The crucifixion was on a Friday

All four Gospels place the death on the "Preparation", the day before the Sabbath.

Firm
John 18:28; 19:14 against Mark 14:12-17

Passover eve or Passover day

John has Jesus die as the Passover lambs were killed; the first three Gospels place a Passover meal the night before.

Disputed
Astronomy (lunar calculation)

Friday Passovers, 26-36 CE

Of the years 26-36, the Friday dates are 7 April 30 and 3 April 33 for Nisan 14; Nisan 15 fits only under looser assumptions.

Computed
Luke 3:1-2

"The fifteenth year of Tiberius"

Luke dates the start of John the Baptist's preaching to Tiberius' fifteenth year.

Probable
John 2:20; Josephus, Ant. 15.380

"Forty-six years" building the Temple

John's figure, counted from Herod's start in about 20/19 BCE, gives a Passover early in Jesus' ministry around 27/28.

Probable
Mark (one Passover) against John (three)

The length of the ministry

The Synoptic outline fits a single year; John mentions three Passovers.

Disputed
Gal 1:18; 2:1; Acts 18:12 (Gallio)

Paul's chronology

Counting back from Paul's dated stay in Corinth, his conversion falls within a few years of the crucifixion.

Probable
Luke 3:23

"Jesus was about thirty"

Luke's "about thirty" at the start of the ministry is an approximation.

Weak
Acts 2:20; the lunar eclipse of 3 April 33

The "moon turned to blood"

A partial lunar eclipse rose over Jerusalem on 3 April 33; some read Peter's quotation of Joel as an allusion to it.

Weak
Africanus; Origen

The darkness reported by Thallus and Phlegon

No solar eclipse can occur at Passover, which falls at full moon.

Weak
← All clues

Paul's chronology

GradeProbable

The Christian case

Paul's letters, the earliest Christian writings, give an independent check. Paul went up to Jerusalem "after three years" () and again "fourteen years after" (), and Acts places him before Gallio, proconsul of Achaia (). An inscription, a letter of the emperor Claudius to Delphi dated to 52 CE, names Gallio as proconsul, which fixes Paul's stay in Corinth at about 51-52 and shows Acts using the right title for the right man at the right time. Counting back from there puts Paul's conversion within a few years of the crucifixion, a check that comes from outside the Gospels.

What the research found

Probable. Counting back with the ancient inclusive count puts Paul's conversion at about 31-36 CE, and the crucifixion before it. This sits more easily with 30 than with 33, but does not exclude 33.

Explore the counterarguments

The count depends on assumptions: that the second visit is the Jerusalem meeting of about 48-49, as it usually is taken to be, and that the years are counted inclusively, as was common in antiquity. Gallio's term could be 52-53 rather than 51-52. The result gives only a latest likely date for the crucifixion, not the year itself.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close